Gifts Under $50

2180 products

Mud Pie painted platter with Santa sleigh over a snowy village and wooden tongs
Santa Scene Plate Set – Painted Platter with Wooden Tongs
$67.00
$67.00
Mud Pie footed candy dish on a green nutcracker pedestal with blue rim
Green Nutcracker Candy Dish – Footed Ceramic Dish with Nutcracker Stem
$47.00
$47.00
Mud Pie Dear Santa Bring Wine stemless wine glass with wooden lid and Santa stopper
Bring Wine Glass & Stopper Set – Stemless Glass with Wood Lid
$39.00
$39.00
Mud Pie Pour Me Some Holiday Cheer stemless wine glass with peppermint swirl stopper
Holiday Cheer Santa Wine Glass & Stopper Set – Stemless Glass with Wood Lid
$39.00
$39.00
Mud Pie cream enamel Christmas tree board with tree handled spreader tied with twine
Tree Spreader Tree Enamel Board Set – Tree-Shaped Board with Spreader
$47.00
$47.00
Mud Pie All The Jingle Ladies stemless wine glass with wooden lid and reindeer stopper
Jingle Ladies Wine Glass & Stopper Set – Stemless Glass with Wood Lid
$39.00
$39.00
Mud Pie footed candy dish on a red nutcracker pedestal with painted bowl
Red Nutcracker Candy Dish – Footed Ceramic Dish with Nutcracker Stem
$47.00
$47.00
Mud Pie cream enamel Christmas tree board with nutcracker handled spreader
Nutcracker Spreader Tree Enamel Board Set – Tree Board with Nutcracker Spreader
$47.00
$47.00
Mud Pie scalloped stoneware Mary tidbit plate with gold star in kraft gift box
Mary Tidbit Plate – Scalloped Stoneware Plate in Kraft Box
$21.00
$21.00
Mud Pie scalloped stoneware angel tidbit plate with gold halo in kraft gift box
Angel Tidbit Plate – Scalloped Stoneware Plate in Kraft Box
$21.00
$21.00
Mud Pie nutcracker hostess set with ceramic tray, printed napkins and tree spreader
Nutcracker Hostess Set – Ceramic Tray, Napkins and Spreader
$67.00
$67.00
Mud Pie scalloped stoneware cross tidbit plate with red ribbon in kraft gift box
Cross Tidbit Plate – Scalloped Stoneware Plate in Kraft Box
$21.00
$21.00
Mud Pie whimsy Christmas triple tidbit dish with present, tree and Santa sections
Whimsy Christmas Triple Tidbit – Three-Section Ceramic Serving Dish
$56.00
$56.00
Mud Pie Santa enamel coated metal tidbit plate with gold rim
Santa Metal Tidbit Plate – Enamel Coated Metal Tray
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie red block print enamel coated metal tidbit plate with gold rim
Red Block Metal Tidbit Plate – Enamel Coated Metal Tray
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie wrapped present design enamel coated metal tidbit plate with gingham bow
Bow Metal Tidbit Plate – Enamel Coated Metal Tray
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie green floral block print enamel coated metal tidbit plate with gold rim
Green Block Metal Tidbit Plate – Enamel Coated Metal Tray
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie Bow Santa hostess set with ceramic Santa tray, bow napkins and candy cane spreader
Bow Santa Hostess Set – Ceramic Napkin Tray with Spreader
$69.00
$69.00
Mud Pie Santa and presents ceramic salt and pepper shakers in a red metal sleigh
Santa Present Salt & Pepper Set – Ceramic Shakers in a Metal Sleigh
$40.00
$40.00
Mud Pie white ceramic cross with a raised gold heart at the centre
Gold Heart Cross – Clear Acrylic Cross with Raised Gold Heart
$27.00
$27.00
Mud Pie small ceramic Christmas tree sitter with snow-tipped branches and pink bow topper
Small Bow Tree Sitter – Ceramic Christmas Tree with Bow Topper
$39.00
$39.00
Mud Pie large ceramic Christmas tree sitter with snow-tipped branches and bow topper
Large Bow Tree Sitter – Ceramic Christmas Tree with Bow Topper
$56.00
$56.00
Mud Pie small tiered ceramic Christmas tree sitter in sage glaze with cream star
Small Tree Sitter – Tiered Ceramic Christmas Tree with Star
$40.00
$40.00
Mud Pie large tiered ceramic Christmas tree sitter in sage glaze with cream star
Large Tree Sitter – Tiered Ceramic Christmas Tree with Star
$56.00
$56.00
Mud Pie medium ceramic Christmas tree sitter with snow-tipped branches and cream bow topper
Medium Bow Tree Sitter – Ceramic Christmas Tree with Bow Topper
$46.00
$46.00
Mud Pie medium tiered ceramic Christmas tree sitter in sage glaze with cream star
Medium Tree Sitter – Tiered Ceramic Christmas Tree with Star
$49.00
$49.00
Mud Pie white ceramic cross with a gold intaglio cross medallion
Intaglio Cross – Clear Acrylic Cross with White Ceramic Gold Medallion
$27.00
$27.00
Mud Pie whitewashed wood nativity plaque with painted Holy Family and gold star
Nativity Plaque – Whitewashed Wood Block with Painted Nativity
$39.00
$39.00
Mud Pie green and white striped ceramic Merry Christmas photo frame with red bow
Green Stripe Bow Frame – Ceramic Merry Christmas Photo Frame
$48.00
$48.00
Mud Pie square fused glass plate with hand-painted green wreath and red bow
Wreath Fused Glass Plate – Hand-Painted Square Christmas Plate
$43.00
$43.00
Mud Pie reindeer stoneware tray with FA LA LA pattern, red gingham napkin and snowman spreader
Reindeer Tray & Towel Set – Stoneware Tray, Gingham Napkin and Spreader
$47.00
$47.00
Mud Pie Christmas tree and stocking paper guest towels in a clear acrylic caddy
Stocking Tartan Guest Towel & Caddy Set – Paper Towels in Acrylic Caddy
$49.00
$49.00
Mud Pie Santa tartan paper guest towels in a clear acrylic caddy
Santa Tartan Guest Towel & Caddy Set – Paper Towels in Acrylic Caddy
$49.00
$49.00
Mud Pie Train One-Piece cream cotton knit baby one-piece with red trains and green Christmas trees
Train One-Piece – Cotton Knit Christmas Baby One-Piece
$42.00
$42.00
Mud Pie Christmas Tree Rollneck Sweater in deep red with crocheted green trees
Christmas Tree Rollneck Sweater – Cotton Yarn Knit with Crochet Trees
$71.00
$71.00
Mud Pie Aurora the Unicorn standing plush in cream with shimmer horn and rainbow ribbon mane
Aurora The Unicorn Plush Pal – Standing Plush with Shimmer Horn
$44.00
$44.00
Mud Pie Iris the Dragon standing plush in lavender with velvet wings and ribbon streamer mane
Iris The Dragon Plush Pal – Standing Plush with Velvet Wings and Ribbon Mane
$53.00
$53.00
Mud Pie Lyra the Pegasus standing plush in pink with shimmer wings, horn and rainbow ribbon mane
Lyra The Pegasus Plush Pal – Standing Plush with Shimmer Wings and Horn
$44.00
$44.00
Mud Pie small hand-painted glass pumpkin sitter with green vine detail and curled glass stem
Small Painted Glass Pumpkin Sitter – Hand-Painted Vine & Floral Detail
$49.00
$49.00
Mud Pie Holiday Plush Pals assortment in cotton rope basket with pink Santa, sage tree and reindeer
Holiday Plush Pals – Faux Fur and Minky Plush with Weighted Seat
$61.00
$61.00
Mud Pie Mini Christmas Plush Pals in five designs - snowflake, tree, Santa, pink reindeer and brown reindeer
Mini Christmas Plush Pals – Miniature Fur Plush with Name Tag
$27.00
$27.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin ballet pointe shoes Christmas ornament with pink ribbon hanger
Ballet Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin Pointe Shoes with Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin basketball hoop Christmas ornament with navy ribbon hanger
Basketball Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin Hoop with Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin soccer ball Christmas ornament with green grosgrain ribbon hanger
Soccer Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin with Grosgrain Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin cheer megaphone Christmas ornament with white ribbon hanger
Cheer Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin Megaphone with Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin baseball glove and ball Christmas ornament with navy ribbon hanger
Baseball Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin Glove and Ball with Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin football Christmas ornament with red grosgrain ribbon hanger
Football Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin with Grosgrain Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie hand-painted resin golf ornament with pin flag and ball on green grosgrain ribbon
Golf Ornament – Hand-Painted Resin Green and Flag with Ribbon
$22.00
$22.00
Mud Pie church stoneware trinket dish in wooden crate with kraft shreds
Church Trinket Dish – Stoneware Dish in Wooden Crate
$25.00
$25.00
Mud Pie gingerbread man enamel coated metal trinket dish
Gingerbread Enamel Trinket Dish – Enamel Coated Metal Ring Dish
$22.00
$22.00

The sweet spot for gifting. Under $50 is where thoughtful meets generous — enough to feel like you really thought about it, without the "did I overdo this?" spiral.

This is where you'll find the candles she's been eyeing, the jewelry that looks twice the price, and the little luxuries that make people feel chosen. Free wrapping. Always.

Restocked weekly. If you need help narrowing it down, DM us — we love a hard assignment.